top of page
  • RealClearPolicy

Congress Must Act Now to Protect Data Privacy

Op-ed by Committee for Justice director of public policy Ashley Baker published in The Hill.

The Fourth Amendment was established in a time when privacy expectations could be articulated through a simple maxim that “every man’s home is his castle.” In the 21st century, however, our most private information is often guarded not by walls or with a key, but by the companies — Microsoft, Verizon, and the like — that provide us with access to the data cloud. In a perfect world, the technologies of today would be met with the same principles that were laid out in the Fourth Amendment by our founders. Unfortunately, that is easier said than done. Technology has added lots of complications, and we are left trying to figure out what a reasonable search is in the age of the data cloud. Much of the doctrine of the Fourth Amendment is based on definitions that are ill-equipped for dealing with challenges in the era of cloud computing. For instance, do emails, location information, and other data and documents stored in the cloud fall within the Fourth Amendment’s protection of “The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects”?

Moreover, lack of notice to the person whose property is being searched has become a big problem in the digital era. Traditional searches of one's home or car are, as a practical matter, difficult to keep secret from the property’s owner. In contrast, absent legal protections, it is easy for the government to search electronic data that is held by a third party without the owner of the data ever finding out about it, assuming the government has the cooperation of the third party.

That is just one of several ways in which the third